St. Pete Beach vs. Clearwater Beach: Which Should You Visit?

If you're planning a Florida beach getaway, chances are you've come across two of the Gulf Coast's most beloved destinations: St. Pete Beach and Clearwater Beach. Both offer sugar-white sand, stunning sunsets, and endless sunshine—but each has its own vibe, attractions, and hidden gems. So how do you choose?
​
As the Crystal Bay Historic Hotel, nestled in the heart of St. Petersburg and just minutes from St. Pete Beach, we're here to help you decide with a friendly breakdown of what makes each beach special—and why staying in St. Pete just might give you the best of both worlds.

Pass-a-Grille Beach

Photo by Jared. CC 2.0 

Pier 60 Clearwater Beach

Photo by Matthew Paulson. CC 2.0

Atmosphere & Vibe

• St. Pete Beach: More laid-back and charming, St. Pete Beach is known for its old Florida vibe, cozy beachfront cafes, and local favorites like Pass-a-Grille. It's the kind of place where you can take a peaceful morning walk along the shore without crowds, then spend the afternoon sipping coffee at a beachside café. For travelers seeking peace, authenticity, and a local's perspective, St. Pete Beach feels like a step back into a simpler, sunnier time.
• Clearwater Beach​​: Lively and bustling, Clearwater draws big crowds thanks to its wide beach, Pier 60, and abundance of tourist-friendly attractions. This is where you’ll find street performers, souvenir shops, and beachside hotels with rooftop bars. It’s ideal for families, first-time Florida visitors, or anyone looking to pack in as much activity as possible.

Kayak at St. Pete Beach

Pirate Cruise at Clearwater Beach

Things To Do

• St. Pete Beach: Stroll through historic Pass-a-Grille with its quaint shops and local art galleries. Rent a kayak or paddleboard and explore the calm waters and hidden coves. Sunset cruises and dolphin-watching tours depart regularly, offering a romantic way to end your day. You can also venture inland—just a 15-minute drive from Crystal Bay Hotel—to explore downtown St. Pete's cultural scene, including the Dalí Museum, the Chihuly Collection and the Museum of Fine Arts.
• Clearwater Beach: This area is packed with activities for all ages. Visit the Clearwater Marine Aquarium, home to Winter the dolphin. Take a pirate-themed boat cruise or parasail over the Gulf. Pier 60 hosts nightly sunset celebrations with artisans and performers, making it a lively hub for evening entertainment. And don’t forget mini-golf, go-karts, and boat rentals—there’s no shortage of ways to stay active.

Dining and Nightlife

• St. Pete Beach: Dining here is an experience in and of itself. Whether you're in the mood for fresh-caught grouper or handmade tacos with a view, there's a locally-owned gem to match. Buoy's Waterfront Grill in St. Pete Beach offers seafood with a view, while Swigwam Beach Bar offers craft cocktails with casual flair. The nightlife tends to be low-key, centered around beach bars like Jimmy B’s or live music at The Toasted Monkey.
• Clearwater Beach: Home to more well-known chains and a high-energy atmosphere, Clearwater's dining scene is all about variety and volume. From beachfront pizzerias to upscale rooftop dining, the area caters to tourists who want options. Nightlife here is vibrant—think nightclubs, beach parties, and live DJ sets.

Crowds and Accessibility

• St. Pete Beach: Generally less crowded and more accessible, with easier parking, fewer high-rises, and a more relaxed pace. That makes it perfect for romantic getaways, solo retreats, and guests who want a stress-free vacation. The beach itself feels more open and calm, even during peak season.
  
• Clearwater Beach: Gorgeous but crowded, especially on weekends and holidays. Parking is expensive and limited, and the beach often gets packed by midday. For some, the lively buzz is part of the appeal. For others, it can be overwhelming.
  

Accommodations: Why Crystal Bay Hotel Stands Out

Crystal Bay Hotel Courtyard

If you're looking for a peaceful retreat with vintage charm and top-notch hospitality, Crystal Bay Hotel is the perfect home base. Located in the quiet yet central west side of St. Petersburg, our historic hotel offers easy access to both beaches—just a 10-minute drive to St. Pete Beach and 30 minutes to Clearwater.

Our hotel has a rich history dating back to the 1910s, with past guests including baseball legend Babe Ruth and movie star Marilyn Monroe. While the architecture retains its classic elegance, the rooms are modern, comfortable, and clean. Guests often compare the vibe to a boutique bed & breakfast—with the added bonus of a large hot breakfast buffet, cozy verandas, and personal service that makes you feel like family.
​
Many of our guests mention the exceptional hospitality of our staff, the peacefulness of our garden and pool area, and the attention to detail throughout the hotel. Whether you’re traveling for a romantic weekend, a girls’ getaway, or a solo adventure, Crystal Bay offers the kind of quiet luxury that feels like a true escape.

Local Tips & Hidden Gems

• In St. Pete Beach: Head to Coconut Charlies on St. Pete Beach for a sunset dinner with your toes in the sand. Explore the Gulf Beaches Historical Museum for a glimpse into the area's past, or rent a beach cruiser and explore the coastline on two wheels.
• In Clearwater: For a quieter moment, try Sand Key Park just south of the main beach. It's often less crowded and just as beautiful. Love shopping? The nearby Cleveland Street District has boutiques and galleries worth checking out.

John's Pass

Fort Desoto Dog Beach

Day Trips and Nearby Attractions

From Crystal Bay Hotel, you can explore more than just beaches. Take a quick drive to John’s Pass Village in Madeira Beach for seafood shacks, watersports rentals, and dolphin-watching tours. Head east to downtown St. Pete for murals, art walks, craft breweries, and waterfront parks. Or explore nature with a visit to Fort De Soto Park, just a 20-minute drive away, offering kayaking, birdwatching, and some of the most unspoiled beaches in the state.

Final Verdict

So, St. Pete Beach or Clearwater Beach? The answer depends on the kind of vacation you're dreaming of. If you love vibrant energy, bustling boardwalks, and a packed itinerary, Clearwater might be your match. But if you're looking to unwind, soak up authentic Old Florida charm, and enjoy a more relaxed pace, St. Pete Beach wins the day.
​
And when you stay at Crystal Bay Hotel, you don’t have to choose. You'll be perfectly positioned to enjoy both beaches, all while coming home each night to a quiet, charming retreat. Book your stay today and discover why so many travelers call us their “hidden gem” on Florida’s Gulf Coast.